Search:

bilaterals.org > Key issues > Investment
publish
quick search




(0)     
Reko Diq saga: Balochistan wins again

posted 20-February-2013

The Nation, Pakistan

Reko Diq saga: Balochistan wins again

By Our Staff Reporter

20 February 20 2013

ISLAMABAD - Amidst continuing violence plaguing Balochistan, there is now a cause of joy for the Baloch people and the government.

In the parallel arbitration lodged by the corporation, TCC, before the International Chamber of Commerce International Court of Arbitration (ICC ICA), the tribunal has denied TCC any relief under its interim measures application and has supported the arguments of the provincial government.

The case before the ICC ICA was lodged in late 2011 and over the course of the year the government vehemently contested the same. In an obvious attempt to exert pressure on the government not only did the company TCC made two requests for arbitration (one before the ICC ICA against Balochistan and another before the International Center for the Settlement of Investment Disputes against Pakistan) but it had also made two similar requests for interim relief.

Instead of capitulating to the pressure, the Balochistan government and the federal government contested the arbitrations and the interim relief applications.

Through the interim measures application, TCC wanted Balochistan to stop its plans for working on the H4 deposit in Reko Diq in the interest of Balochistan and Pakistan, claiming that Balochistan would damage the area and that TCC would suffer irreparable harm.

The legal team representing Balochistan, comprising of ASC Ahmer Bilal Soofi, QC Arthur Marriott, QC Cherie Booth and Advocate General Balochistan Mahnaz Malik and Amanullah Kanrani vehemently contested the case. Dr Samar Mubarakmand gave witness testimony before the ICC tribunal.

The legal team was successful in proving to the tribunal that TCC would not suffer any irreparable harm if Balochistan were allowed to continue with its plans. In fact, it has now been established that Balochistan is working on the site for the benefit of the Baloch people and Pakistan in general.

It is also established that Balochistan would suffer more loss than TCC if it were ordered to stop its plans. The ICC tribunal should be commended for giving weight to and deciding on the matter in view of the representations made by the Government of Balochistan over the speculation offered by TCC.

The government had previously won in ICSID on a similar interim measures application and the ICSID tribunal had also given weight to Pakistan’s representations and had allowed the Balochistan government to continue with its plans for Reko Diq.

Later the Supreme Court held that TCC’s contract was illegal, void and non est after hearing and rejecting TCC’s arguments. The detailed judgment of the Supreme Court is awaited but it has been established by the Supreme Court that TCC does not have any rights over Reko Diq under the contract. There is now no obstacle for the Government of Balochistan to exploit the natural wealth of the Province for the betterment of the people.

keywords : ICSIDinvestor-state disputesminingPakistan source :

Comment on this article

TTIP debate - Brussels | 19-Apr-2014

more...