- About bilaterals.org
- Feb-2016: New ISDS platform launched
- Sep-2004: Launch announcement
- Feb-2015: Relaunch of bilaterals.org
- Mar-2013: Relaunch of bilaterals.org
- Jun-2009: Relaunch of bilaterals.org
- Dec-2008: An update from bilaterals.org and logo design contest announcement
- Dec-2006: bilaterals.org in Spanish & French
- Sep-2006: Update from bilaterals.org
- How to participate
- Key issues
- Texts of agreements
Tribunal confirms ₹10,247-cr tax demand on Cairn UK
The Hindu | 10 March 2017
Tribunal confirms ₹10,247-cr tax demand on Cairn UK
The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, in an order passed on March 9, has ruled that Cairn UK Holdings will have to pay ₹10,247 crore in short term capital gains tax on an internal share sale dating back more than ten years.
The tribunal, however, rejected the tax department’s demand for back-dated interest on this liability of ₹18,800 crore, saying the interest only came into effect because of a retrospective amendment made to the Finance Act, 2012. The company could not have foreseen such an amendment at the time, the tribunal held.
The tax dispute between the Indian government and Cairn Plc has also been the subject of international arbitration from 2014. But the tribunal has said the tax liability case could be heard locally, without prejudice to the arbitration.
Tax treaty googly
This latest order, though, is likely to make matters uncomfortable between the UK and Indian governments. The former has been lobbying for the tax liability to be pardoned under a bilateral tax treaty.
The tax liability goes back to 2006, when Cairn India acquired the local assets of Cairn UK Holdings, giving the UK firm a 69 per cent equity holding in return. While the I-T department said the value of this indirect transfer of shares was based on local assets, including highly productive oilfields in Rajasthan and the Krishna-Godavari basin, the UK company asserted that it was an internal re-grouping and hence not subject to Indian taxes.
The share transfer came to light when Cairn India was publicly listed in 2007.
In August 2010, Anil Agarwal’s Vedanta Resources Plc acquired a controlling interest in Cairn India. Cairn Energy Plc still holds a 9.82 per cent stake in Cairn India.
In its submission to the tribunal, Cairn Plc said Cairn India Holdings Ltd. is incorporated in Jersey. The gain, if any, on a transfer of shares is not even deemed to be taxed in India.
Assets located in India
The tribunal, however, ruled that the real effect of the transfer of shares of Cairn India Holdings Ltd will be the transfer of control of the assets of subsidiaries in India, thereby making the capital gain taxable in India.
Cairn also tried to liken its tax dispute to the $2-billion tax penalty imposed on Vodafone International Holdings in 2007 for payments the telecom operator had made to Hutchison Telecom. The Supreme Court had thrown out the tax case against Vodafone in January 2012. (The retrospective amendment to the Finance Act mentioned earlier was made after this judgement; the tax case is now under international arbitration.)
However, the tax department distinguished the Cairn tax dispute from that of Vodafone’s. “In the case of Vodafone,” it contended, “it was payment from (one) non-resident to (another) non-resident. But in the present case, a resident company i.e. Cairn India Ltd has made payment of ₹26,681.87 crore to the Appellant (Cairn UK Holdings). In the present case, money was actually remitted out of India (as consideration) to purchase the shares.”
News from the movements
24-Apr-2017 GRAINTenemos por delante, potencialmente, una ola de nuevas normas de “comercio, inversión y cooperación”, y nuestra región se verá fuertemente presionada a aceptar más abusos e indefensión ante las empresas.
24-Apr-2017 USWAfter three decades of NAFTA, Mexican workers are still denied basic rights.
21-Apr-2017 Chile Mejor sin TPPSus representantes afirmaron que tratados como el TPP, el TISA y otros acentúan el extractivismo intensivo en uso de agua y atentan contra las decisiones soberanas de los pueblos respecto al medioambiente.
10-Apr-2017 Coalition Nationale "Non aux APE"La Coalition se désole de ce que des citoyens arrivent difficilement à échanger avec les autorités de ce pays sur des questions aussi importantes que les APE et la ZLEC.
7-Apr-2017 Argentina Mejor sin TLCLos pueblos latinoamericanos decimos NO a los Tratados de Libre Comercio ¡Basta de privilegios para las empresas a costa de nuestros derechos!
4-Apr-2017 No al TTIPLa campaña No al TTIP, CETA, TiSA apoya la iniciativa del grupo parlamentario Unidos Podemos – En Comú Podem – En Marea que el Congreso de los Diputados solicite al Tribunal Constitucional un examen sobre si el tratado UE-Canadá viola derechos constitucionales de la ciudadanía tal como se ha hecho en Francia y Alemania.
4-Apr-2017 Forum against FTAsAround 100 representatives of people’s movements from southern Indian states gathered at the Indian Social Institute, Bangalore from 2-3 April to discuss the implications of the proposed mega free trade agreement - Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP).
1-Apr-2017 The MintAfricans are insisting on actual economic development which is leaving European trade negotiators exasperated. Rick Rowden explains why their stand is historic and right.
bilaterals.org is a collaborative space to share information and support movements struggling against bilateral trade and investment deals which serve corporations, not people. Multilingual. Global. No one owns it. Open publishing. Get involved.