US amping up dispute with Canada over allowed exports of American dairy products
Todas las versiones de este artículo: [English] [français]
CBC | 25 May 2021
US amping up dispute with Canada over allowed exports of American dairy products
by James McCarten
The United States is ramping up its dispute with Canada over the sale of American dairy products north of the border — the first significant new trade squabble between the two countries of the post-NAFTA era.
U.S. Trade Representative Katherine Tai formally requested a dispute settlement panel Tuesday to examine allegations from American producers that Canada is denying them fair access to the Canadian market. The request marks a significant escalation of American complaints about the way Canada is allocating access to its supply-managed dairy market under NAFTA’s successor, the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement.
"A top priority for the Biden-Harris administration is fully enforcing the USMCA and ensuring that it benefits American workers," Tai said in a statement. "Launching the first panel request under the agreement will ensure our dairy industry and its workers can seize new opportunities under the USMCA to market and sell U.S. products to Canadian consumers."
At the heart of the dispute is how Canada has distributed its tariff-rate quotas — the quantities of certain dairy products, like milks, cheeses, powders, yogurt and ice cream, that can be imported at lower duty levels.
U.S. trade officials and dairy industry advocates say a large number of those quotas have been allocated to processors rather than producers, effectively denying U.S. farmers their fair share of the supply-managed Canadian market.
That is expressly forbidden under the text of the agreement, USTR officials told a background briefing Tuesday.
"What Canada is doing is essentially dividing up the (quotas) into different pools and saying, ’Well, here’s a pool that only processors can access,"’ said one official, who cannot be identified under the terms of the briefing.
"We read the agreement and we think it’s pretty plain on its face that that’s not permitted. Canada disagrees and so we’re going to argue that out before a panel."
Consultations but no resolution
The two sides held consultations on the issue late last year as a first step "but did not resolve the dispute," the USTR said in a news release Tuesday.
Canadian officials have been insisting for months that the allocations are perfectly in keeping with Canada’s commitments under the trade agreement, which took effect last July.
International Trade Minister Mary Ng said Canada is "disappointed" with the USTR’s decision and that the quota allocations are well within the bounds of the agreement, known north of the border as CUSMA or the "new NAFTA."
"Under CUSMA, Canada agreed to provide some additional market access to the United States for dairy while successfully defending our supply management system and dairy industry," Ng said in a statement.
"We are confident that our policies are in full compliance with our CUSMA TRQ obligations, and we will vigorously defend our position during the dispute settlement process."
The request for a panel puts dairy squarely alongside the ongoing softwood lumber dispute as two of the most prominent trade-related sore spots in the Canada-U.S. relationship. But even healthy relationships have disagreements, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said earlier Tuesday.
"We will always defend supply management and our dairy producers, amongst others. We will always stand up for our forestry workers in the industry across the country," Trudeau said.
"We will continue — as we did successfully in the previous administration — to stand up to defend Canadian interests and values wherever necessary."
