The Pharma Letter
MSF warns on EU/India trade talks
18 January 2016
As reported in Indian media, senior officials from the European Commission and India are expected to meet today in Brussels to hold talks on resuming negotiations on the proposed European Union-India free trade agreement.
The international medical humanitarian organization Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) warned that India must resist European Union pressure to include harmful provisions on intellectual property that could restrict access to medicines for people in developing countries.
EU-India free trade agreement (FTA) talks began in 2007 and have largely stalled since 2013 because of several contentious issues including intellectual property rights. These include provisions that could restrict the production, sale and export of affordable life-saving medicines made in India, upon which millions of people in developing countries rely.
After fierce pressure from groups of people living with HIV, hepatitis C, cancer and other life-threatening diseases, some of the worst provisions such as extensions to patent terms and data exclusivity have been removed from the negotiating text.
IP enforcement measures “could harm generics production and distribution”
However, a range of ‘intellectual property enforcement’ measures proposed in the FTA could have harmful effects on the production and distribution of generic medicines. These measures range from legitimate medicines being blocked from leaving India on their way to people in developing countries if a multinational company claims that their intellectual property (IP) is being infringed upon, to third parties - such as treatment providers - being embroiled in court cases simply for buying or distributing generic medicines. Some of the harmful IP enforcement provisions are similar to those included in the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA), a controversial, pluri-lateral treaty, that did not include India, and which was abandoned by the EU thanks to intense public and political scrutiny.
“As the Indian government considers resuming trade negotiations with the EU, we urge both sides to think about the lives that hang in the balance if access to affordable generic medicines is shut down or blocked due to IP enforcement measures,” said Leena Menghaney, head – India, MSF’s Access Campaign.
Worries about proposed investment chapter
An equally disturbing feature in the proposed investment chapter of the EU-India FTA is the inclusion of intellectual property within the definition of investment, meaning that the rules of the FTA could be used by pharmaceutical companies to sue the government of India in non-transparent, international arbitration - outside of domestic courts - under the controversial investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) mechanism. For example in 2012, the pharmaceutical company Eli Lilly used the ISDS mechanism to launch a legal attack upon the Canadian government for rejecting several of its trivial evergreening patents on medicines, though the courts had independently revoked the patents.
“Both India and the EC should put negotiations on the investment chapter on hold. The EC can no longer legitimately demand that India sign an investment chapter with the controversial outdated ISDS mechanism that the EC is not willing to sign on to itself in the Trans-Atlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP)”, said Helle Aagaard, EU Policy and Advocacy Advisor, adding:“While the reformed ISDS system proposed by Trade Commissioner Malmstöm promises improvements in some areas, it still considers intellectual property as an investment which threatens access to medicines. Countries must always be free to regulate the patent system so they can protect public health and access to affordable medicines without fearing that big pharmaceutical companies will sue them for doing so.”