IISD | November 2017
Is “moonlighting” a problem? The role of ICJ judges in ISDS
by Nathalie Bernasconi-Osterwalder and Martin Dietrich Brauch
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is the principal judicial organ of the United Nations (UN). It is typically the first permanent international court that comes to mind, based on its tradition, broad jurisdiction and importance for the development of public international law. Its 15 full-time judges—elected by states for nine-year terms by the UN General Assembly and Security Council—are held to high standards of ethics and legal competence.
Unsurprisingly, ICJ judges may not act as counsel in any case or participate in the decision of any case in which they previously took part in a different capacity. Neither may they exercise political or administrative functions or “engage in any other occupation of a professional nature,” according to the Statute of the ICJ.
Yet at least 7 current ICJ judges and 13 former ICJ judges have worked—or are currently working—as arbitrators (or annulment committee members at the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes [ICSID]) in investor–state dispute settlement (ISDS) cases during their ICJ terms.
Those 20 individuals were appointed at least 92 times, either during or before the start of their ICJ terms, and served as arbitrators in at least 90 cases while sitting as ICJ judges (see Annex). (In two cases, two sitting ICJ judges served concomitantly as arbitrators in the same tribunal.)
If we consider only the 78 treaty-based cases among those 90 and the full universe of 817 treaty-based ISDS cases known as of July 31, 2017, this means that ICJ judges have sat as arbitrators in roughly 10 per cent of all known investment treaty cases during their tenure.
To our knowledge, there has never been a formal challenge against an ICJ judge for taking on an arbitration case based on the prohibition to “engage in any other occupation of a professional nature.” According to the Statute of the ICJ, it would fall on the court itself to settle “any doubt on this point.”